EMDR or talk therapy for trauma: which is right for you?
By Bibiana Jordan, psychologist (NIP), Amsterdam ·

"I know exactly why I react like this. I've talked about it for years. So why does my body still panic?"
If you've ever said something like this, you're not alone. Many of the internationals I work with in Amsterdam are smart, self-aware and well read. They can explain their childhood, their attachment style and their triggers in detail. And still, a raised voice in a meeting, a cold text from a partner or a flight home for Christmas can send them straight back to feeling small and unsafe.
So when you start looking for help, a question comes up quickly: should I try EMDR, or is talk therapy enough? This post walks through what each one does, what the research says, and how to choose without overthinking it.
What is the difference between EMDR and talk therapy?
"Talk therapy" is a broad name for therapies that work mainly through conversation. You put words to what happened, notice the patterns it left behind, and slowly build a different understanding of yourself, inside a safe relationship with your therapist. Trauma-focused CBT and Schema Therapy are two structured examples.
EMDR therapy (eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing) works differently. You bring a specific painful memory to mind, briefly, while following side-to-side eye movements or another rhythmic left-right stimulus. You don't have to describe the memory in detail. The aim is for the memory to lose its emotional charge, so it feels like something that happened then, not something happening now.
A simple way to put it: talk therapy helps you understand and make meaning of what happened. EMDR helps the memory itself stop feeling so raw.
Why doesn't understanding my trauma make the feelings go away?
Because painful experiences aren't only stored as a story. They're also stored as feelings, body sensations and alarm reactions: a tight chest, a racing heart, a sudden urge to please or disappear. That part of the memory doesn't always respond to logic.
This is especially true for what happened in childhood. If you grew up having to stay alert to a parent's moods, or felt you had to earn love by being good, your nervous system learned that lesson long before you had words for it. As an adult you can know you're safe and still feel unsafe. (I wrote more about this in why we keep repeating the same patterns.)
Insight is valuable. It's often the first step. But for many people it isn't the last one.
Is EMDR better than talk therapy for trauma?
Neither is simply "better". Both are recognised, evidence-based treatments for trauma. The UK's NICE guideline on PTSD recommends offering trauma-focused CBT to adults with PTSD, and offering EMDR to adults whose non-combat trauma was more than three months ago. The World Health Organization has also recommended both CBT and EMDR for people with PTSD. (If you want a closer look at those two, I compare them side by side in EMDR vs CBT for trauma.)
What matters more than the label is the fit: what you're struggling with, how stable you feel right now, and whether you feel safe with your therapist. A good therapist will help you decide, rather than push one method for everything.
When might EMDR be a good fit?
EMDR can be a good choice when:
- One or a few specific memories keep coming back, as images, nightmares or sudden waves of fear
- You already understand your story, but your reactions still feel bigger than the situation
- Talking about what happened in detail feels too much, or has not helped
- Certain situations, sounds or places set off a strong body reaction
When might talk therapy be a better place to start?
Talk therapy may be the better first step when:
- You don't feel steady enough yet to look at painful memories, even briefly
- The pain is less about one event and more about long-standing patterns: people-pleasing, harsh self-criticism, choosing partners who hurt you
- You want to understand where those patterns came from and practise new ways of relating
- You're in the middle of a crisis or a big life change and need support first
Do I have to choose just one?
No, and often you shouldn't. For trauma that goes back to childhood, many people benefit from both. Talk-based work builds safety, understanding and new patterns. EMDR can then be used for the specific memories that still hold a lot of charge. Afterwards, talking helps you make sense of the changes and bring them into daily life.
This is how I usually work. We don't jump into painful memories in the first session. We start by making sure you have enough steadiness to do the work, and we decide together, step by step.
What does an EMDR session feel like?
Before any processing, we spend time preparing: getting to know your history, choosing what to work on, and practising ways to calm your body if things feel intense. When we do process a memory, you stay in control. You can pause at any time.
People often describe it as tiring but lighter afterwards. Some notice changes quickly; for others, especially with childhood trauma, it takes longer. It's normal for memories or dreams to come up between sessions, and we talk about how to handle that.
Can EMDR work online?
Yes, for many people it can. A UK evaluation of 93 clients who had EMDR online in 2020 found reductions in anxiety, depression and trauma symptoms, similar to what you'd expect in person. It was a small study without a control group, so it's a promising sign rather than the final word.
In practice, online EMDR therapy works well if you have a quiet, private space and feel safe there. If home doesn't feel like a safe place right now, meeting in person is usually the better option.
When should I seek support?
You don't need a diagnosis or a "bad enough" story to ask for help. It may be time to reach out if:
- Old memories, nightmares or flashbacks are affecting your sleep, work or relationships
- You feel on edge, numb or ashamed much of the time
- You keep ending up in the same painful situations, even though you can see the pattern
- You've tried books, apps or earlier therapy, and something still feels stuck
If you ever feel unsafe or have thoughts of ending your life, please don't wait: call 112 in an emergency, or 113 Zelfmoordpreventie on 113 or 0800-0113 (free, 24/7).
How I work with trauma in Amsterdam
I'm a psychologist (NIP) working in English and Hungarian with internationals in Amsterdam. Having made the move abroad myself, I know how much harder old wounds can feel when you're far from home and your usual support.
My trauma therapy in Amsterdam combines Schema Therapy, which helps you understand and change the patterns that started in childhood, with EMDR for the memories that still feel raw. I also weave in simple body-based exercises, so you have ways to feel steadier between sessions.
We can meet in person at Osmos Studio, Nassaukade 162/163 in Amsterdam (daytime), on a walking session in Rembrandtpark, or online via secure Google Meet. EMDR sessions are 90 minutes, which gives us time to prepare, process and settle before you leave.
You don't have to know which method you need before you get in touch. Working that out is part of what we do together.
If you'd like to talk it through, you can book a free 15-minute consultation or send me an enquiry.
Book a free consultationWorking on trauma can stir up difficult feelings. If you are in danger or need urgent help, call 112. If you are having thoughts of suicide, contact 113 Zelfmoordpreventie on 113 or 0800-0113 (free, 24/7), or chat via 113.nl. You don't have to go through this alone.
Sources
Common questions
What is the main difference between EMDR and talk therapy?
Talk therapy works mainly through conversation: you put words to what happened, understand the patterns it left and practise new ways of relating. EMDR uses short periods of focusing on a specific memory while following side-to-side eye movements or another left-right rhythm. Its aim is for the memory to lose its emotional charge, and you don't have to describe it in detail.
Is EMDR better than talk therapy for trauma?
Neither is simply better. Both EMDR and trauma-focused talk therapies such as trauma-focused CBT are recommended treatments for PTSD in international guidelines. The right choice depends on what you are struggling with, how stable you feel right now and how safe you feel with your therapist.
Can I do EMDR if I don't want to talk about my trauma in detail?
Yes. In EMDR you bring the memory to mind briefly, but you don't need to describe every detail out loud. Many people find this a relief, especially when talking about what happened has felt overwhelming.
Does online EMDR therapy work?
For many people it can. A UK evaluation of 93 clients who had EMDR online found reductions in anxiety, depression and trauma symptoms, though it was a small study without a control group. Online EMDR works best if you have a quiet, private space where you feel safe.
Can I combine EMDR with talk therapy?
Yes, and for trauma that goes back to childhood this is often helpful. Talk-based work such as Schema Therapy builds safety and changes long-standing patterns, while EMDR can be used for specific memories that still feel raw.
Where can I get EMDR therapy in Amsterdam in English?
I offer EMDR in English and Hungarian, in person at Osmos Studio on Nassaukade in Amsterdam or online via secure Google Meet. EMDR sessions are 90 minutes, and you can start with a free 15-minute consultation via theexpatpracticebyjordan.com.