← All articlesCouples Therapy

The Four Horsemen: Why Couples Keep Having the Same Fight

By Jordan, Psychologist · · 7 min read

Two armchairs facing each other in a calm therapy room, analog film photograph

Why do we keep having the same argument?

Most recurring fights are not really about the dishes or the in-laws. Research by Drs. John and Julie Gottman suggests that many conflicts are perpetual and rooted in differences in personality and needs. What matters most is not solving every problem, but how you talk about it.

The Four Horsemen and their antidotes

  • Criticism: attacking your partner's character ("You never think about anyone else"). Antidote: a gentle start-up. Describe your feeling and need: "I feel overwhelmed, could you help with dinner tonight?"
  • Contempt: sarcasm, eye-rolling, mockery. It is the strongest predictor of separation. Antidote: build a culture of appreciation and respect every day.
  • Defensiveness: counterattacking or playing the victim. Antidote: take responsibility, even for a small part.
  • Stonewalling: shutting down and withdrawing. Antidote: notice when you are flooded, take a 20-minute break, and self-soothe before returning.

Expat couples face extra pressure

When one partner moves for the other's career, or both are far from family, the relationship often carries the weight of every other support system. Differences in language, culture, and how each partner adapts can quietly feed resentment.

What Gottman couples therapy looks like

Gottman Method therapy starts with a structured assessment: a joint session, an online Relationship Checkup, an individual session with each partner, and a feedback session with a shared plan. From there, you practise new ways of managing conflict and rebuilding friendship and intimacy.

Frequently asked questions

What are the Four Horsemen in a relationship?

The Four Horsemen are criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling, four communication patterns identified by Gottman research as predictors of relationship distress and breakup.

Can couples therapy help if we fight all the time?

Yes. Gottman Method couples therapy teaches couples to recognise destructive patterns and replace them with specific, research-based skills for managing conflict.

How much does couples therapy cost at The Expat Practice?

Couples therapy sessions are €150 for 90 minutes. A free 15-minute consultation is available first.

Ready to talk it through?

Book a free 15-minute consultation with Jordan, in English or Hungarian, in Amsterdam or online.

Book a Consultation

Keep reading